I hit this message while building a simple email agent: “We experienced an error while running the workflow.” No context, no helpful error log, that’s it. If you’ve seen this inside OpenAI Agent Builder, you know the vibe. Yeah, because nothing says fun like vague error messages. The good news is, I’ve fixed this multiple times across different nodes, and I’ll show you exactly what worked for me, and hopefully, it’ll work for you too. We’ll cover the two nodes where I faced and solved this error, Agent Node and the Guardrails Node, how to spot what’s actually breaking, and how to fix it without wrecking your build.

If you’re a visual person, feel free to check out this video that describes how to fix the issues.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nDjVRjyw5oU

Spot the Problem: Why Your OpenAI Workflow Keeps Crashing

OpenAI Agent Builder errors usually come down to a few things:

• The wrong node is failing and you’re looking in the wrong place.
• The MCP server connection is broken or not authenticated.
• The tool list is not loading, so the agent can’t call anything.
• The model you picked is being moody and causing timeouts or bad responses.

When my email agent failed, the Agent Node error read: “error retrieving tool list from MCP server” with “method not allowed.” Translation: the agent tried to fetch tools from the MCP server, and the server shrugged. Other times I got “verify your authentication details.” In both cases, the issue wasn’t the agent’s logic. It was the connection and auth setup.

And yes, poor docs make this worse. I remember staring at my screen thinking, what the heck?

Check Your MCP Server Connection First

Start with the boring but crucial part: the MCP server. This fixes a shocking number of issues.

Here’s what I do:

• Open the MCP server you’re using. In my case, it was my rube MCP server.
• Grab the authentication key or token.
• Paste it back into the Agent Builder’s MCP connection for that node, then click Update.
• Click the MCP connection again and let it load the tool list. Don’t immediately disconnect and reconnect. Just let it breathe and load.
• If you see “verify your authentication details,” fix the key and update again.
• Run the workflow and watch it hit the Agent Node. If it keeps running instead of failing fast, you’re in good shape.

When the tool list finally loads and the workflow runs past the Agent Node, that usually means the auth handshake is good and the agent can find its tools. Most of the time, that’s the whole fix.

Switch Models If Your Current One Is Being a Pain

If your connection looks fine and you still get a workflow error, try switching to a different model version. I’ve had more issues with newer models from time to time, so I swap to a lower version like gpt-4.1 or gpt-4.1-mini. I’ve done this mid-debug, and poof, problem solved. Models can be picky, like bad coffee.

In practice:

• Open your node settings for the Agent Node.
• Change the model to gpt-4.1 or gpt-4.1-mini.
• Save, then run the workflow again.

For me, older versions ran more reliably when the newer ones acted up. If you want the newer model’s reasoning for debugging, you can switch back once things are stable.

Guardrails Node Not Guarding Well

I’ve had Guardrails crash on me with no helpful context. In one case, the real problem was moderation inside the Guardrails Node. The workflow error hid what was really happening.

So I had to use the elimination method to solve this thing, didn’t know I’d use the term again years after school 😂

• First, preview the workflow to reproduce the failure.
• Uncheck “Continue on error” inside Guardrails. This makes Agent Builder show the actual error instead of a vague workflow failure.
• Preview again. You should see a more specific error from moderation.
• If moderation looks like the problem, toggle moderation off in Guardrails.
• Preview again. If the workflow runs, you found the culprit.

I unchecked a box and suddenly it worked.

Uncover Hidden Errors by Disabling Continue on Error

This is my favorite quick probe. When the workflow fails and the UI gives you nothing but “workflow failed,” uncheck “Continue on error,” then preview again. The system will stop hiding behind a generic message and will usually tell you what broke. I’ve seen errors like “invalid URL” or “type invalid” from moderation once I did this. That’s your starting point.

It’s simple: make the system spill the beans, then fix the exact thing it complains about.

Ditch Moderation If It’s the Real Villain

If the error points to moderation, try disabling it inside Guardrails. Then preview again. When I did this, my workflow went from dead to done in seconds. If you need moderation for production, treat this as a temporary fix to confirm the root cause. You can re-enable it later once you adjust settings or wait out a flaky update.

Debug Agent Node Errors Like a Pro

The Agent Node can be sneaky. It might be failing because it can’t load tools, or because the model is misreading your instructions. One underrated trick is to preview the node with a message and use a model that exposes reasoning traces. When I do this, I can watch the agent’s thinking and spot where it goes off the rails.

In my case, I had a booking flow. One agent needed to output a classification in JSON. Another agent needed to ask for details like name, date, and time. The model flagged a conflict in its thoughts: “I notice there’s a conflict between the instruction to ask for details and the requirement to output classification in JSON.” It then picked one path and ignored the other. That’s how you get weird outputs.

So I fixed the instructions, then previewed again until the internal reasoning lined up. The workflow started flowing.

Use Reasoning Traces to Fix Prompt Confusion

Here’s what I do step by step:

• Open preview on the Agent Node and send a simple prompt, like “Hi, I need to make a booking.”
• Watch the agent’s internal reasoning. If it shows a conflict, that’s your clue.
• Look for things like: the agent trying to classify and ask follow-up questions at the same time, or the agent trying to output JSON when it does not have all the fields.
• Rewrite the instructions so the model does not have to guess.

Example fix:

• If your booking agent must collect name, number, date, and time, say so.
• Tell it to store those in memory first, and only proceed when all are present.
• Tell it to output the final result in JSON with the exact keys you want.

I saw my agent second-guessing itself and I fixed the prompt right there.

Be Super Specific in Your Agent Instructions

Vague prompts are an invitation for trouble. If you want a clean handoff, spell out exactly what to collect, when to ask, and what to output.

Try something like this for a booking agent:

• You must have these fields before proceeding: name, phone number, date, time.
• If any field is missing, ask a direct question to get that field, one at a time.
• Store the fields in memory.
• When you have all fields, output JSON only, with keys: name, phone, date, time.
• Do not include extra text outside the JSON.

That level of clarity saves you so much time. Test, tweak, preview, repeat. Agents are smart but dumb. Give them vague instructions, and they’ll smile while breaking your flow.

If you want a complete build walkthrough, I put together a full no-code appointment agent tutorial that connects Gmail and sends email after booking. You can watch it here: Build a no-code AI appointment agent that connects Gmail.

Quick Fix Checklist

• MCP connection: open your MCP server, copy the auth key, paste and update inside Agent Builder, then load the tool list.
• Model swap: if the workflow still fails, switch to gpt-4.1 or gpt-4.1-mini, then test again.
• Guardrails probe: uncheck “Continue on error,” preview, read the real error.
• Moderation toggle: if moderation is the culprit, disable it and preview again. Re-enable later if needed.
• Reasoning debug: preview with a model that shows reasoning, spot conflicts in instructions, and rewrite prompts to be exact.

Conclusion

The fix for “We experienced an error while running the workflow” is usually not magic. It is a handful of practical steps that make your agent less confused and your stack less fragile. Start with the MCP connection, then try a model switch. If Guardrails is acting up, force it to show the real error and toggle moderation if needed. Use reasoning traces to clean up messy prompts. I’ve been there, and now my workflows hum along. If you want to see a complete build in action, watch my tutorial on building an appointment agent that sends email after booking: Step-by-step no-code appointment agent with Gmail. Grab your setup and fix that error today. And if you’re stuck on a different node, drop a comment with the exact error and where it fails. Let’s get your OpenAI Agent Builder troubleshooting done and your workflow running.

Sharing is caring!